What Makes Us Tip More or Less?
Whether or not we tip depends a lot on the service received, as well as whether or not we think we'll be returning to the same establishment. Sometimes we leave tips simply because it is expected -- that and the fact that we don't want to appear to be cheap to our dining companions by "stiffing" the server. Believe it or not, a lot of research has gone into why we tip and what makes us tip more or less for similar service. Tipping is not always simply a sign of a job well done.

The most prominent reason for tipping appears to be more of a guilt issue than a gratitude issue. We know that tipping, at least in the United States, is expected, and if we don't tip we stand the chance of angering the server, and then who knows what our next visit to that restaurant, airport or garage will be like! Also, our assumption that tipping is designed to encourage good service for our next visit may or may not be accurate. What if we are at a restaurant that we know we won't be back to? What then is our motivation to tip? Some argue that it is a way of making ourselves feel better about being served because we know the waiter works hard and isn't paid well.

Guilt issues aside, research has shown that the quality of the service we receive isn't always reflected in the tip we leave. Many who have studied the practice have discovered that excellent service only draws a marginally higher tip than average service. Other things the server might do, however, do make more of a difference -- probably without our even realizing it! For example, Cornell University's Center for Hospitality Research has conducted several studies revealing some interesting facts about server habits that can boost tip percentages. Here are a few of them:

  • Touching - Waiters experienced a tip increase from 11.8% to 14.8% of the check total when they briefly touched the shoulder of the customer. Both men and women left higher tips when touched, and although younger customers increased their tip amount more, all ages increased the tip by some amount.

  • Squatting - Two studies showed that waiters who squatted next to the table when taking orders and talking with customers increased their tips from 14.9% of the bill to 17.5% of the bill in one study, and from 12% to 15% in another study. Apparently, the eye contact and closer interaction creates a more intimate connection and makes us want to give the server more money.

  • Giving candy - A study that involved giving customers a piece of candy with their bill showed an increase in tip percentage from 15.1% to 17.8%. Another study in which servers gave each customer two pieces of candy with the bill increased the tip from 19% to 21.6% of the bill. Still another study showed that the way the server gave the customer the candy had the largest impact on the increase of the tip: This study had the server initially give each member of the customer's party one piece of candy and then "spontaneously" offer a second piece of candy. This method increased the tip to 23% of the bill!

  • Being helpful - A study of hotel bellmen revealed that just taking a few extra minutes explaining to guests how to operate the television and thermostat, opening the drapes for guests, and offering to fill the ice bucket increased tips from $2.40 to $4.77.

Want to get an earful of arguments on both sides of the fence about tipping? Visit the forums at The Original Tipping Page. You'll see (and can join in on) many arguments about why tipping should be banned, why tipping should be mandatory, why tips shouldn't be "expected," and why owners should just pay a decent wage.